Choreography is one of those arts that is especially difficult to master, because it requires so many different resources for its development. Dancers, music, costumes, lighting, and some place to stage the performance make a challenging list of components. Yet rarely is it creativity or competence in the development of these components that most challenges new choreographers (well, most choreographers). It’s the mastery of the process.
This is probably because most choreographers see the challenge of their work as a straight line in front of them, a list of what has to be done before the piece is finished. Perhaps the single biggest benefit of experience is that this approach becomes more circular. Each of the complex parts of a choreographic work informs the choices made in the others, and when worked through as a list, an essential part of the creative process is lost, and the piece, although perhaps brilliantly conceived, rarely realizes its actual vision.
Of the most successful projects that I’ve participated in, I don’t think a single one actually went onstage with exactly the same music that the choreographer originally brought to me. It turns out to be incredibly valuable to a choreographer to make a complete version of the score, and begin to work with it, at the earliest possible stage of the process. Many choreographers are reluctant to do this, because they feel they haven’t yet found the right music; in fact, nothing will help a choreographer find the right music faster than choreographing to not-quite-the-right-music. It immediately clarifies the details of what the right music has to be.
There may well be an insight in this into the entire process of choreography. In order to make the right decisions, there must be a gradual but steady increase of focus into the details of those decisions. This requires covering the same ground again and again to some degree, some amount of going in circles. If each circle moves you forward, though, it may well be the most creatively effective way to go from a beginning to a successful completion.